Movies are rated on
a Scale of 1 to 4 stars with 4 stars being best.
By Jeff Wilser
RATING:
Starring: Ben
Stiller, Chris Rock, Jada Pinkett Smith, David Schwimmer, Sacha
Baron Cohen, Cedric the Entertainer, Andy Richter, Gwen Stefani.
Written by: Mark Burton, Billy Frolick. Directed
by: Eric Darnell, Tom McGrath
Rated PG for mild language,
crude humor and some thematic elements.
It’s
cute but not great. Directed by Eric Dannell (“Antz”)
and Tom McGrath, “Madagascar”
teems with fun one-liners, snappy references, and warm, life-affirming
friendships. Kids will love it. Unfortunately for us adults, the
story comes up short on danger and conflict, reducing it to a
breezy comedy with one dimension.
Like
every animated kid movie—although “Madagascar”
is computer-animated, technically—the heroes are all talking
animals. Specifically, they’re animals trapped in New York’s
Central Park Zoo, a mostly happy bunch that entertains the school
children and tourists.
Marty the Zebra (Chris Rock),
who “doesn’t know if he’s a white zebra with
black stripes, or a black zebra with white stripes,” suffers
a midlife crisis. He’s turning ten, the big “One O,”
and laments that he’s never left the zoo, never seen the
wild, never seen much of anything. He’s listless. In one
of the film’s many nods to older viewers, Marty says wistfully,
“Maybe I should just go to law school.”
His friends try to cheer him,
led by Alex the Lion (Ben Stiller), Melman the Giraffe (David
Schwimmer), and Gloria the Hippo (Jada Pinkett Smith). But Marty’s
having none of it. He decides to break out of the Central Park
Zoo and head to the wild, the great unknown: Connecticut. This
whole sequence is a great jab at New Yorkers; much like two million
smug, self-satisfied Manhattanites, these animals, excepting Marty,
have no interest in ever leaving the island.
One
key subtlety makes “Madagascar”
marginally more interesting than the usual animal-breaking-from-captivity
story: these animals don’t hate their prison. They’re
not tortured. There’s no Wilbur going to the slaughter.
Those devices, while appealing in their own right, are fairly
black and white: the animals are being mistreated, and they flee
to safety. “Madagascar,”
written by Mark Burton and Billy Frolick (both first-time feature
film writers), explores an issue that’s more nuanced, more
adult: ennui.
Taking his cue from a sharp-witted
flock of penguins (who steal the movie with their mean-spirited
charm), Marty makes up his mind, sets his sights on the jungles
of Connecticut, and breaks free of Central Park Zoo. Afraid for
Marty’s life, his friends follow. What follows is a Shrek-worthy
jaunt through the streets of Manhattan, as the animals fuss over
the best way to get to Grand Central (Lex or Park?), getting directions
from cabbies, and going to Metro North, where they have to settle
on the Stamford Local. Perfect satire of the adult commute.
Sadly,
the fun starts to plateau. The one-liners are funny enough, the
animals are cute enough, and the film is referential enough—winking
at classics like “Planet of the Apes” and recent stuff
like “Castaway”—but ultimately, the overarching
plot is not compelling. There’s little sense of real loss,
real danger. Unlike “Lion King,” say. Or even “Shrek.”
The story heats up towards the
end, when, after a sequence of mildly amusing mishaps, the animals
find themselves marooned on Madagascar. Some tension and conflict
(finally) emerges, as the domesticated Alex the Lion, encouraged
by Marty, connects with his natural sense of violence, his genetic
predisposition to hunt. And kill.
Soon
Alex poses a real threat to the friends, since, hungry in the
wild, all he can think of is steak. In a delightfully disturbing
visual, when Alex looks at his friends, they begin to turn into
steaks. For a kid’s movie, the concept is actually quite
dark: freed from the norms of society, Alex is willing to slaughter
his friends.
Alex’s inner-struggle against
his predatory nature is engaging, scary, and easily the most interesting
stretch of the film. But it’s too little, too late, and
ultimately doesn’t push far enough. The 8-year-olds will
feel a real sense of danger, but most adults won’t buy it.
“Madagascar”
has the feel of a sequel that will surely follow: funny, harmless,
and pleasant enough, but without the heartbeat of an urgent story.