Movies are rated on
a Scale of 1 to 4 stars with 4 stars being best.
By Jeff Wilser
RATING:
Starring: Jennifer
Lopez, Jane Fonda, Michael Vartan, Wanda Sykes, Adam Scott. Written
by: Anya Kochoff, Richard LaGravenese. Directed by:Robert Luketic
Rated: PG-13
for sex references and language.
If you
liked “Maid in Manhattan,” boy, are
you going to love “Monster-in-Law.”
And if you liked getting your left arm chopped off, you’ll
really enjoy getting your right arm chopped off, too.
Jennifer
Lopez stars as Charlie, the blandest woman alive. She’s
single. She’s lonely. She’s boring. In the movie’s
forgettable opening act, Charlie lounges on the beach with her
closest friends, a pack of dogs. (No, this does not refer to Jane
Fonda. We’ll get to her later.) She spots a hunky shirtless
jogger (Michael Vartan), they make eye contact, and they bump
into each other later in the coffee shop. It’s gripping
stuff.
Later, Charlie tediously recounts
this action to her annoying friends, who include the stereotypical
token gay-guy, who later leaves for a “mani and a pedi.”
They chat. They laugh. (We don’t.) It’s much like
a sitcom on the WB, only those don’t cost ten bucks, and
those mercifully end in 30 minutes, not 90.
While catering at a party, Charlie
finally introduces herself to the hunky jogger, who turns out
to be a successful doctor named Kevin. With the monotony of two
actors getting a paycheck, Charlie and Kevin banter and flirt,
reminding us that miracles do happen: if this script can get turned
into a movie, then there’s hope for all of us, even the
least-talented.
Meanwhile, a Barbara-Walters-esque
TV personality, Viola Fields (Jane Fonda), learns that her career
is over. Notorious for her alcoholism, hot temper, and smothering
personality, Viola is a flat-out bitch. The only one who keeps
her in check is her loyal assistant, Ruby (Wanda Sykes), who is
responsible for 10 of the film’s 12 funny moments. Since
her career is over, Viola decides to focus all of her stormy attention
to her son, who happens to be (surprise!) the doctor, Kevin.
Director
Robert Luketic (who helmed the much more enjoyable “Legally
Blonde”) then makes the only good decision in the movie:
he surges the plot forward several months, not bothering to show
the period where Charlie and Kevin fall in love. Smart. He spares
us the obligatory dating-montage, instead cutting to what we want
to see: the showdown between J-Lo and Jane Fonda.
Kevin brings Charlie home to meet
Viola, the two women seem to hit it off, so he pops the big question.
Charlie says yes. You can guess what happens. Viola gets jealous,
hates the bride, and dedicates her sorry existence to poisoning
the wedding and saving her son from what she considers a mistake.
This should be good comic material.
Somewhat derivative of “Meet the Parents,” but still.
The nightmare mother-in-law vs. the sweet-natured bride. The problem
is, Jane Fonda’s performance is more irritating than funny.
Her histrionics, fake-tears, and outbursts have all the comic-joy
of a clown slapping you in the face, repeatedly. The first slap
is so unexpected maybe it’s kind of funny. But then it’s
just painful, you want the clown to stop, and you want your money
back.
The
humor’s biggest flaw? The jokes are telegraphed. While at
lunch, Charlie tells Viola, for almost no reason, that she’s
allergic to a certain ingredient. Hmmmmm….. Do we think
that might come up again to haunt her? So at the wedding’s
rehearsal dinner, when Viola spikes the gravy with said ingredient,
we’re not at all surprised, and we’re certainly not
laughing. Or take this minor offense: Viola says that at her own
wedding, her mother-in-law wore not a white dress, but a black
dress . . . [long pause] . . . “in mourning.” Ha.
And poor Jane Fonda. Why? Is promoting
her book really that important? After a 15 year hiatus, she comes
back to the silver screen . . . for this. Giver her credit: she
puts it all on the line, she immerses herself in the bitchy character,
and you can tell that she’s honest-to-God trying. But why?
It’s as awkward as watching Michael Jordan miss dunks while
sucking wind with the Washington Wizards. Ugh.