Movies are rated on
a Scale of 1 to 4 stars with 4 stars being best.
By Jeff Wilser
RATING:
Starring: Michael
Keaton, Deborah Unger, Ian McNeice, Chandra West, Colin Chapin,
Anastasia Corbett, Mike Dopud, Aaron Douglas, Miranda Frigon,
Mitchell Kosterman. Written by Niall Johnson. Directed by Geoffrey
Sax.
Rated PG-13 for violence,
disturbing images and language
Do you
know the number of people in the continental United States who
call themselves “Michael Keaton fans?” I do. The number,
not counting his family, is seven. Not seven hundred thousand.
Not seven hundred. Just seven. I know this because I’m one
of them, one of the few.
My
belief in Keaton runs deep. Sure, he might have dropped off Hollywood’s
radar screen, but he’s still one of the best actors at portraying
the “ordinary guy” in very unordinary circumstances.
His characters are easy to like, his range is surprising, and
underneath his chipper banter lurks just the hint of darkness.
For the last few years I’ve
had a hunch—okay, delusion—that someday, from out
of nowhere, Keaton would star in a surprise hit, garner a chic
Oscar nomination, and then skyrocket to a John Travolta-esque
comeback. Hey, if Travolta could recover from “Look Who’s
Talking Now” (the second limp sequel, not the first), then
why couldn’t Keaton bounce back from “Jack Frost?”
And who knows? Someday, maybe
he will. But one thing’s certain: the comeback’s not
going to start with “White
Noise.” For the film is just that: white
noise, static, vanilla—a generic suspense-horror-thriller
that’s both uninspired and unremarkable. It’s not
laughably bad, but rather a ghost story that’s not scary,
not creepy, and not worth your attention.
As
“White Noise” opens, we’re introduced to the
happy-looking life of Jonathan Rivers (Keaton), a well-to-do architect
who’s a “got it all” family man. Rivers is a
less-comedic “Mr. Mom,” a loving father who needs
to get his son to school and make sure that he eats his cereal.
Keaton nails these kind of small scenes; even a simple line to
his son like, “You want some OJ, buddy?” feels real,
feels right.
Moments later his wife—not
his son’s mother, incidentally, but this fact seems completely
irrelevant to the film—Anna (Chandra West), finds out that
she’s pregnant. And this, sadly, is where the film’s
problems begin. There’s nothing likable about Anna. There’s
nothing not to like, either—she’s just boring. She
has no nuances, no quirks. Which is weird, since she’s supposedly
an “acclaimed international author.” Couldn’t
the writer (Niall Johnson) give her just one line of good dialogue,
just one line? If she was a minor character, this wouldn’t
much matter. But within two minutes of this happy little couple’s
pregnancy-moment, Anna gets in her car and dies. Oops! Poor Jonathan.
(For those squeamish about spoilers, don’t worry—this
happens ten minutes into the film.)
Yet
Anna’s not a minor character. Even though she only has three
minutes of screen-time, her death is treated like a tragedy, and
for about forty minutes it’s this traumatic event, or whatever,
that’s supposed to lend poignancy. Because up to that point,
the movie sure as hell isn’t scary. It’s not funny.
And since Anna is so melba toast, we don’t feel any loss,
so it’s not dramatic, either.
As Jonathan copes with the loss
of his wife (and as we’re checking our watches), he gets
some weird messages on his cell phone and notices radio-static
in odd places. Eventually he learns about “Electronic Voice
Phenomenon,” or EVP, a belief that the dead can communicate
with us through electronic devices—anything from TVs to
cell phones. Whatever. Curiously, there are many people out there
who actually believe in this mumbo-jumbo, and judging by the movie’s
opening quotation (which defines EVP for the audience), and by
the closing stanzas, director Geoffrey Sax wants you to take the
concept seriously.
Yet for an interminable length
of time, these EVP signals don’t seem in the least bit dangerous.
There’s no sense of threat. For a horror film—or even
a supernatural thriller—this is a cardinal sin. Is Anna
trying to reach him from the grave? Or does he just have a really
crappy cell phone plan? We don’t care. The signals are treated
far too matter-of-factly for us to be scared. And since Jonathan
doesn’t personally seem to be in danger, we’re never
creeped out.
Gradually,
Jonathan grows more and more obsessed with using EVP to receive
messages from his wife. He builds a Batcave-looking room that
has a dozen or so TVs and computer monitors, hoping to electronically
record her voice and image. He succeeds. Yet this revelation is
lost on us, since we never had any reason to care about Anna or
their relationship.
Finally, about 50 minutes into
the film, these EVP messages, and the souls that convey them,
seem capable of physically hurting Jonathan and those that he
cares about. There are some malevolent ghosts, in the shadowy
form of three faceless men, who want to kill the living. As Jonathan’s
obsession swells, soon he tries to protect complete strangers
from these not-very-scary phantoms. Too little too late. The end
of the film contains some genuinely frightening moments, but they
don’t justify the prior 50 minutes of tedium.
That’s not to say there
aren’t bright spots. The production design (from Michael
S. Bolton—no, not that one) darkens as the tone of the film
gradually shifts from Jonathan’s sunny-beginnings to his
eventual obsession. But a “good production design”
is hardly a reason to go see a movie. That’s like saying
that you should have booked a ticket on the Titanic because the
food was first-rate.
[Sigh.] I should start bracing
myself for a straight-to-video “Jack Frost 2.”